Government accountability office gao issued a revised version of the government auditing standards also known as the yellow book, which updated the independence rules. List of changes in the yellow book making the report on internal controls and compliance on a financial audit available in. Attendees will leave with an expanded knowledge of compliance and yellow book topics. Or, what is my auditor going to be asking that i should be prepared for. Understanding the new independence rules related to. Yellow book meets yellow cake and all sorts of delicious changes posted by guest blogger on oct 22, 2018. This practice aid is intended to provide an illustration of one methodology that could be used by an auditor. However, the gao requires documentation of significant threats to independence along with the related safeguards employed. To do this, auditors rely on these standards to provide a framework for conducting highquality audits with competence, integrity, objectivity, and.
Among the more significant changes in the 2011 revision of government auditing standards was the introduction of a new conceptual framework for auditor independence, which completely replaced the former overarching prin. Understanding the changes to yellow book independence february 21, 2019 governmental audit quality center todays speakers nancy miller, cpa kpmg brian schebler, cpa rsm 2 what we will cover 3 independence requirements under the aicpa code of professional conduct and the 2018 edition of government auditing standards the 2018 yellow book. Plus, the gao considers assistance with financial statement preparation to be a significant threat to independence that requires the employment of a safeguard. Added guidance to address situations in which government auditors work. The double difficulty of financial statement preparation. Although the 2018 yellow book changed the rules regarding auditor independence, it did not change the responsibility of management with. While it wont be effective for financial audits until june 30, 2020, yearend audits, there are changes to the auditor independence rules that you will need to start considering now. The new standards include changes to clarify and harmonize the yellow book with existing aicpa standards. Recent changes to international auditing standards. Professional standards updates psus summarize recentlyissued standards of major auditing and accounting standard setting bodies.
This aicpa practice aid titled, 2011 yellow book independence non audit services documentation practice aid, is intended to help auditors performing audits under the 2011 edition of government auditing standards referred to as the 2011 yellow book to comply with its independence rules. Ill be writing articles about the more significant changes soon. The 2011 yellow book is available on the yellow book section of the gao web site. Yellow book revisions update independence guidance journal of. One of the most notable changes, and the one discussed in this article, is related to the independence requirements when an auditor provides nonattest services to the client by. For auditors performing single audits, these yellow book standards present new requirements and expand activities that can call auditors independence into question. The yellow book is used by auditors of government entities, entities that receive.
The author summarizes the most significant changes in the new yellow book, with particular focus on the new standards for evaluating threats to auditor independence. Government accountability office gao are designed to provide a framework for highquality governmental audits, which include audits of government entities and entities receiving government awards. The most significant change made in the 2018 yellow book relates to the independence standards. Auditor responsibility under the yellow book unconditional requirements auditor must comply with where relevant. Inform and teach participants about the changes to the yellow book 2. Government accountability office gao issued a revised version of government auditing standards gas, often referred to as the yellow book. The updated version of the yellow book contains changes in six specific areas. Understanding the changes to yellow book independence.
Separate personnel perform the audit and preparation of accounting records and financial statement services. Updating government auditing standards the 2018 yellow book. Revised gao and aicpa independence rules audit conduct. Broadcasts new yellow book impacts auditors preparing tribal financial statements july 29, 2018. Consideration of independence in the yellow book gagass practical consideration of independence consists of. Gao also issues guidance on implementing and complying with standards. Government auditors are required to objectively evaluate government operations, gather sufficient, appropriate evidence, and report the result.
To assist participants in assessing the impact of changes on current practice. The cpe hour requirement stays the same at 24 and 56. One of the key changes under the new framework is the requirement for auditors to identify threats to independence and then assess the significance of those threats. New statements on auditing standards and the yellow book.
A threat to independence is not acceptable if it either a could impact the auditors ability to perform an audit without being affected by influences that compromise professional judgment or b could expose the auditor or audit organization to circumstances that would cause a reasonable and informed third party to conclude that the. This howto manual for auditors provides a framework for conducting audits of tribal governments and other. Government auditing standards gagas, also known as the yellow book, which includes substantive changes to the independence rules. Gao issues revised yellow book standards for government. Also known as the yellow book, the revision supersedes the 2011 revision of the standards.
To assist participants in complying with the yellow book when conducting audits in conformity with these standards. The general accounting offices government auditing standards gagas have been revised for the first time since 2011. The 2018 yellow book includes a new concept referred to as waste and there are new considerations for the auditors role in addressing waste. Therefore it is understandable that the yellow book conceptual framework will be used more often than the aicpas. The revised standards also known as the yellow book, or gas. Definition of common terms used in the yellow book are expanded. The new december 2011 yellow book a slippery slope for. I just finished comparing the 2011 yellow book to the 2018 yellow book. There are other changes in the 2018 revision of the yellow book that mainly relate to the auditors responsibilities with regards to cpe, and identifying fraud, waste, and abuse.
Gao issues revised yellow book standards for government auditors. Auditors may use the yellow book in conjunction with professional standards issued by gao and other authoritative bodies. Chapter 3 ethics, independence, and professional judgment perhaps the most impactful changes in the 2018 yellow book standards are in the area of auditor independence and how that is potentially affected when the auditor prepares draft financial statements andor performs certain non. The yellow book now makes clear that an auditor preparing financial statements in their entirety creates a significant threat to independence. An auditor could use various approaches to meet the independence evaluation and documentation requirements of the 2011 yellow book. However, the gao did add application guidance that emphasizes the need to obtain gagasspecific cpe especially when there are revisions to the standards. How the yellow books new independence standards impact. Update on the developments in government auditing standards. The government accountability office issued the new 2018 edition of government auditing standards the yellow book. How the new 2018 yellow book impacts your audit eide bailly llp. If the auditor cannot sufficiently overcome the threat to his or her independence, the auditor cannot write the financial statements and conduct the audit. New gao yellow book clarifies independence requirements. Conceptual framework for independence auditors should apply the conceptual framework at the audit organization, engagement team, and individual auditor level to. There were many improvements and changes made to the new yellow book.
Key 2018 yellow book independence rule changes 2018 yellow book independence guidance for government audit organizations 15 recognizes that audit organizations in government entities frequently provide services that differ from the traditional professional services a firm provides these types of services are often provided. The 2018 revision of the government auditing standards commonly known as the yellow book contains numerous changes, and getting a handle on these changes can be challenging. Here is a list of the changes that caught my eye in the order they appear in the revised edition. This list does not explain the changes it only points them out. Some of you may wonder, how is this update going to affect me. Primary yellow book changes 5 updated independence included a conceptual framework focused on converging where practical incorporated clarified sass fewer differences added documentation requirements additional documentation in independence focus on nonaudit services made minor changes for performance audits. Yellow book meets yellow cake and all sorts of delicious. A common understanding with management regarding responsibilities for nonattest services.
A threat to independence is not acceptable if it either a could impact the auditor s ability to perform an audit without being affected by influences that compromise professional judgment or b could expose the auditor or audit organization to circumstances that would cause a reasonable and informed third party to conclude that the. Yellow book revisions update independence guidance. The 2018 yellow book is here and there are several key changes your. Im aware there have been varying interpretations on this topic among. The yellow book is for use by auditors of government entities, entities that receive government awards, and other audit organizations performing yellow book audits. Auditors cannot prepare financial statements from clientprovided trial balances or accounting records as this. Expansion of the independence standard to state that preparing financial statements from a clientprovided trial balance or underlying accounting records generally creates significant threats to auditors independence. Getting a handle on 2018 revisions to the yellow book. Audit must be conducted by an independent auditor auditors must follow gagas yellow book auditor must determine whether financial statements present fairly in conformity with gaap and the schedule of federal financial awards is presented fairly in relation to the fs. Waste is defined in the 2018 yellow book as the act of using or expending resources carelessly, extravagantly, or to no purpose. In terms of yellow book cpe, many of the proposed changes in this area were removed in the final version. The most significant change to the standards relates to how auditors evaluate the nonaudit services they. Celebrating 40 years of excellent client service omb 2cfr chapter 1 and chapter ii, parts 200, 215, 220, 225 and 230 uniform administrative requirements. The last revision to the government auditing standards yellow book was in 2011.
Finally, notforprofit organizations need to be alert to the independence period. Gagas performance audit standards video course includes an online videos and selfstudy manual for 2 hours of cpe credit the government accountability office gao released an updated version of the yellow book in 2018. Later that year, the professional ethics executive committee peec of the american institute of certified public. Gagas, also known as the yellow book, provide a framework for conducting high quality audits with competence, integrity, objectivity, and independence. Managements ability to oversee nonattest services based on their requisite skills, knowledge and experience. Government accountability offices april 2017 exposure draft ed that could affect their governments. The yellow book update and new independence standards. Yb yellow book key changes made in the 2018 yellow book.
Auditor independence the standards guide auditors who prepare the financial statements of audited entities whose services may impair their. Auditors cannot prepare financial statements from clientprovided trial balances or accounting records as this creates a significant threat to independence. The purpose of this blog is to explore resources to assist you in getting a handle on the changes made to the yellow book, not in a matter of days but an hour or two. While the guidance in the yellow book pertains to auditors, government officials should be aware of some of the proposed changes in the u. Gao releases proposed changes to yellow book auditing. The government accountability office gao published a revised version of the generally accepted government auditing standards gagas, also known as the yellow book, which includes substantive changes to the independence rules when a firm performs bookkeeping or financial statement preparation services for a client. Per the 2018 yellow book, auditors must be independent from. The gagas performance audit standards video course highlights the crucial updates performance auditors need to know, including independence, cpe requirements, and. The government accountability office gao has recently updated the government auditing standards this year.
696 131 328 661 666 1573 383 309 1475 766 1033 453 520 424 1215 862 1227 1287 722 186 1437 209 1233 982 861 1224 533 479 147 114 1461 385 802 3 839 478 892 1350 21 987 565 1014 999 1315 1372 1259